My secret favorite SP song. What is yours?

Comments

Showing the first 50 of 67 comments. Read them all on fan.day.

• basementcore October 12, 2026

  “Doomsday Clock” gets less love than it deserves; I’ll take that riff over half the obvious picks.

• AmberSatellite86 October 12, 2026

  absolutely—“doomsday clock” should be in every set, that riff is way too good to leave behind.

• coldghost October 12, 2026

  “Pale Horse,” easily.

• bsidechorus98 October 12, 2026

  “the sacred and profane” has always been ridiculously underrated to me. that whole Adore atmosphere gets me every time.

• AnalogHeadliner October 12, 2026

  Yes, it has that hazy after-midnight feel. My secret pick is “Set the Ray to Jerry” — never gets old to me, fr.

• arcadesounds October 12, 2026

  zeitgeist hive is clocking in

• cherryclub October 12, 2026

  great pick, but “Obscured” is my secret weapon every time tbh.

• analogsynth October 13, 2026

  “Pug” tbh — bleak in the best possible way, and Adore stays wildly underrated.

• OliviaDee October 13, 2026

  Don't laugh, but I love Christmastime 😂

• coastallover October 13, 2026

  No laughing here—“Christmastime” is charming, and that melancholy little glow suits them perfectly.

• cassettehead October 13, 2026

  “Set the Ray to Jerry” is mine; it has that hazy, slightly dangerous feeling I never get tired of.

• ColdDrums October 13, 2026

  “Glynis” is mine; it feels like the band quietly built a whole storm around that melody.

• bsidechorus98 October 13, 2026

  “Obscured” forever, that one hits me harder than half the huge singles.

• ampcrowd October 13, 2026

  “The Aeroplane Flies High” — massive, moody, and somehow still not talked about enough.

• coldclub October 14, 2026

  Absolutely. It feels like an entire second finale, not just a deep cut. The quiet middle stretch makes the final surge hit even harder.

• ambercassette October 14, 2026

  “To the Grays” for me. That chorus is absurdly catchy, and I’m still convinced it deserved way more noise.

• cosmicwave October 14, 2026

  Absolutely no laughing—great pick.

• cosmicwolf October 14, 2026

  to the grays absolutely rips 🔥

• BasslineWave October 15, 2026

  Obscured wins on vibes alone.

• basementcore October 15, 2026

  “Obscured” is unfairly good for something that could’ve stayed a deep cut. Mine might be “Daphne Descends” — gloriously weird in exactly the right way.

• cosmic_head03 October 15, 2026

  “Whir” has never left my rotation.

• AnalogHeadliner October 15, 2026

  “Soothe” is quietly perfect, imo.

• cherryclub October 15, 2026

  Glynis is SUCH a sleeper pick

• AmberSatellite86 October 16, 2026

  exactly, that last surge is why i’d take it over half the obvious singles.

• BlueOrbit October 16, 2026

  “Soothe” is the kind of deep cut that makes the whole secret-favorite question feel unfair.

• BasslineWave October 16, 2026

  Soothe is almost unfairly good.

• CoastalWave October 16, 2026

  Mine might be “The Boy.” It’s such a sweet little left turn, and I’ll defend it forever.

• AmberSatellite86 October 16, 2026

  “Silverfuck” is my pick — give me the sprawling guitar chaos over another spin of “1979” any day.

• amber_record October 17, 2026

  silverfuck clears 1979 pretty easily tbh, but "here is no why" might be my real secret pick.

• ambercassette October 17, 2026

  Set the Ray to Jerry is unreal.

• analog_demo October 17, 2026

  silverfuck supremacy, no notes

• coldbridge85 October 17, 2026

  “Doomsday Clock” is the rare deep-ish pick that would absolutely flatten a room live. No notes, just turn it up.

• ColdDrums October 17, 2026

  Mayonaise still takes it for me.

• cosmic_head03 October 18, 2026

  “Daphne Descends” deserves more love.

• AmberSatellite86 October 18, 2026

  soothe is absolutely top tier.

• ampcrowd October 18, 2026

  “Set the Ray to Jerry” absolutely earns that title; I’d put “Obscured” right beside it.

• coldclub October 18, 2026

  “Blew Away” is mine, easily.

• coldbridge85 October 19, 2026

  Especially live—“Silverfuck” is basically a controlled demolition with guitars.

• cosmictide October 19, 2026

  set the ray to jerry is basically too good to be a secret pick anymore lol

• BsideMoon October 19, 2026

  Here Is No Why is unreal.

• amber_record October 19, 2026

  “pennies” tbh, adorable in a way the big dramatic stuff never quite is.

• coldbridge85 October 19, 2026

  “Pug.” Tiny song, maximum emotional wreckage.

• cosmicwave October 20, 2026

  It has that strange, suspended feeling that makes it hard to compare with anything else in the catalog. I would still sneak “The Boy” into this conversation, though.

• BrightDemo02 October 21, 2026

  “Set the Ray to Jerry” is mine. I’ll take that hazy, slow-burn side of the Pumpkins over the obvious picks every time.

• AnalogHeadliner October 21, 2026

  The Boy is ridiculously charming, fr.

• cosmicwave October 21, 2026

  Great pick. “Set the Ray to Jerry” feels like it could keep unfolding forever, and I never get tired of that guitar atmosphere. Mine might be “Daphne Descends” — it has that same patient, slightly haunted pull.

• cosmic_head03 October 21, 2026

  “Frail and Bedazzled” is mine—those guitars make it feel much bigger than it gets credit for. 💫

• arcadesounds October 21, 2026

  “Obscured.” quietly devastating.

• cosmicradio11 October 22, 2026

  “The Aeroplane Flies High” easily, tbh.

• AnalogHeadliner October 25, 2026

  “Pug” is such a good pick, fr — that whole Adore mood gets under my skin.