Listen & Vote · Beach House
By fan.day ·
Separated by 18 years, Love Story (2008) and Patient Zero (2026) are both amazing songs. Do you have a favorite?
Vote on fan.day to see the results.
Showing the first 50 of 70 comments. Read them all on fan.day.
lunarrooftop October 28, 2026
Love Story is untouchable pop nostalgia, but Patient Zero has me fully obsessed right now. I’m voting now 🗳️
feedback_head October 28, 2026
Love Story, easily. Patient Zero may grow on me, but that chorus has a grip most newer Taylor songs can’t quite match.
arcade99 October 28, 2026
Patient Zero, no hesitation tbh.
loudmotel October 28, 2026
Love Story. no contest lol
motel97 October 28, 2026
Love Story, because apparently i’m contractually obligated to pick 2008.
BasslineWave October 28, 2026
Patient Zero. forward motion, sorry.
quietsounds October 28, 2026
love story still clears imo
ravenghost70 October 28, 2026
I voted Patient Zero. Love Story is a classic for a reason, but I like when a newer song can actually feel like a real contender instead of just losing to nostalgia by default.
coldghost October 28, 2026
Patient Zero — I’ll take the newer song when it’s this close.
basementcore October 28, 2026
Patient Zero; nostalgia has had a pretty good run.
quiet_setlist October 28, 2026
patient zero, because 2008 has been winning enough elections already.
DemoClub81 October 28, 2026
Patient Zero — let the present have one win, damn 😭
rustyghost October 29, 2026
Love Story is the obvious pick, but I respect Patient Zero making this less of a nostalgia landslide.
reverbwolf October 29, 2026
Patient Zero. Love Story has already had a very successful campaign cycle.
lowkeydiner October 29, 2026
Patient Zero. New era, new obsession.
coldbridge85 October 29, 2026
Love Story. Some campaigns never end.
foxwave October 29, 2026
Love Story. I’m not changing my vote just to make the results look cooler.
latehead October 29, 2026
love story, easily — that chorus is permanently lodged in my brain lol
hollowsounds October 29, 2026
love story. boring vote, correct vote.
BrightDemo02 October 29, 2026
Love Story, no hesitation.
DemoCassette October 29, 2026
love story, but i’m refusing to call it a boring vote; that song earned every bit of its staying power.
papersignal October 29, 2026
love story, easily. no contest.
rooftopcore October 29, 2026
Patient Zero has my vote, easily.
AnalogHeadliner October 30, 2026
Patient Zero, tbh. I’m an old-song person by nature, so that feels like a mildly shocking vote from me lol.
CoyoteCore October 30, 2026
patient zero. i like surprises.
honey_lantern October 30, 2026
Love Story. Patient Zero is interesting, but that melody is impossible to argue with.
ravenghost70 October 30, 2026
Patient Zero. I like the left-field pick.
neonlantern October 30, 2026
Patient Zero for me — i love when the newer song actually steals the whole vote.
coastalmoon October 30, 2026
Patient Zero, no question. I’ll always take the newer, weirder turn when it lands — Love Story already has enough defenders in here lol.
ChorusLover October 31, 2026
love story still wins for me; the melody is just too locked in.
rooftopfox03 October 31, 2026
patient zero. newer taylor clears.
cassettehead October 31, 2026
The 2008 production has my heart.
Echo91 October 31, 2026
Love Story. That chorus is permanently lodged in my brain, sorry to the new one 😭
foxplaylist November 1, 2026
love story forever, sorry patient zero 😭
melody_kid November 1, 2026
Love Story, comfortably—the newer one may be stranger, but that chorus still has the cleaner emotional hit.
drums_fader09 November 1, 2026
Love Story, forever.
mothsynth November 1, 2026
Patient Zero. I like the risk.
mothcinema November 1, 2026
Patient Zero, easily 🔥
melody_kid November 1, 2026
Love Story, but only just.
cosmic_head03 November 2, 2026
Love Story for me. I’m predictable enough to pick the one that feels like it belongs on an old burned CD, but Patient Zero has made this a much closer poll than I expected. 🌙
paleghost02 November 2, 2026
Love Story. Court has adjourned.
ghostclub November 3, 2026
Patient Zero. Love Story is huge, but I’ll take the weirder new direction every time.
RavenKid66 November 4, 2026
love story; the new one can keep its mysterious medical chart.
orbit70 November 5, 2026
Patient Zero; Love Story is great, but I’ll take the newer choice here.
amber_record November 5, 2026
patient zero, and i’m glad it isn’t trying to out-love-story “love story” tbh
BlueOrbit November 6, 2026
Patient Zero. diagnosis: good song.
fadedowl November 6, 2026
I’m with you, but “Love Story” still has the better title.
rooftopfox03 November 7, 2026
same, i’ll take the newer one too — “Love Story” is basically impossible to dethrone as a title though.
glassvinyl November 7, 2026
Patient Zero; it feels more like a door opening than a victory lap.
RetroTapes November 7, 2026
diagnosis: correct.