You have to choose one. Which is it? 🥹

Comments

Showing the first 50 of 59 comments. Read them all on fan.day.

• cassettehead October 23, 2026

  Starboy, easily.

• BasslineWave October 24, 2026

  Starboy. Blinding Lights is fine but y’all have streamed it enough for all of us 😭

• coldclub October 24, 2026

  Blinding Lights for me; Starboy is cooler, but that chorus still gets me every time.

• Orbit October 24, 2026

  Starboy for the colder, more cinematic mood; it still feels like a whole world.

• neonlantern October 24, 2026

  same. “Starboy” just has that instant swagger—i’m never getting tired of it.

• ChorusLover October 24, 2026

  Starboy. Blinding Lights is massive, but Starboy still has the sharper edge for me.

• kicklover October 24, 2026

  Starboy; Blinding Lights is almost too polished for me, even if the live version gives it more bite.

• reverbwolf October 24, 2026

  Starboy. Blinding Lights has done enough cardio on every playlist already.

• AnalogHeadliner October 24, 2026

  Exactly, Starboy has that icy swagger—Blinding Lights is undeniable but it’s been played into the earth lol.

• RainyHarmony65 October 24, 2026

  starboy easy lol. blinding lights is undeniable but starboy has way more swagger.

• melody_kid October 24, 2026

  i'd keep Starboy; Blinding Lights is undeniable, but Starboy has more personality.

• arcadesounds October 24, 2026

  starboy. no further questions.

• GardenGhost October 25, 2026

  Blinding Lights — sometimes the obvious answer is obvious because it wins.

• retroghost October 25, 2026

  obvious can still be overrated.

• moonghost73 October 25, 2026

  Starboy. The title alone wins.

• hollowsounds October 25, 2026

  blinding lights. the giant mall-song allegations are not enough to make that synth line stop working on me 😭

• lunarrooftop October 25, 2026

  Starboy EASY 😭

• melody_kid October 25, 2026

  Blinding Lights. Starboy is cooler on paper, but the build and release on Blinding Lights still win for me.

• MidnightDiner October 25, 2026

  Correct answer, honestly.

• cosmicraven October 25, 2026

  blinding lights owns my brain tbh

• Moon October 25, 2026

  blinding lights, no hesitation.

• motel99 October 25, 2026

  Yeah, Starboy has the cooler menace. Blinding Lights is basically unavoidable at this point, which is not really its fault, but still.

• drumscore98 October 25, 2026

  Blinding Lights, but only by a little. Starboy has the cooler atmosphere; Blinding Lights just has that ridiculous momentum that never really wears off.

• kicklover October 25, 2026

  Starboy. “Blinding Lights” is great, but it has been played into the ground for me.

• melody77 October 26, 2026

  Blinding Lights, sorry to the cool kids — that synth line still wins every single time.

• rooftopclub October 27, 2026

  Blinding Lights, idc lol

• cosmicwave October 27, 2026

  Starboy for me; Blinding Lights is a monster, but Starboy still feels sharper and less exhausted by its own success.

• RestlessMelody October 27, 2026

  Starboy, easily. Blinding Lights is huge, but I never get tired of that colder, cockier Starboy vibe.

• AnalogHeadliner October 27, 2026

  Blinding Lights for the chorus alone; it turns every listen into a dramatic montage lol.

• needle_kid October 27, 2026

  Starboy’s whole sound still clears for me—Blinding Lights had its moment, but I’m picking the darker track every time.

• moonghost73 October 28, 2026

  Starboy. “Blinding Lights” is probably the better pop machine, but Starboy still has some actual menace left in it.

• rainyhighway October 28, 2026

  that synth line is undefeated

• moon32 October 28, 2026

  starboy. blinding lights is overrated.

• arcade_tape October 29, 2026

  I’m still taking Starboy. It’s colder and a little weirder, which is exactly where I want Abel.

• BasslineWave October 29, 2026

  Exactly—Blinding Lights is basically engineered in a lab; Starboy still sounds like it might ruin your evening.

• foxplaylist October 29, 2026

  still hits every single time 😭

• lunarrooftop October 30, 2026

  Starboy — colder, weirder, and that hook still hits like it knows it’s expensive 😮‍💨

• arcade99 October 30, 2026

  I’m taking Starboy — it makes even the most boring moment feel like a runway entrance lol. Blinding Lights is untouchable pop, but Starboy has my vote.

• recordbassline October 31, 2026

  Starboy, without much debate—Blinding Lights is immaculate pop, but Starboy has more personality and I’d take the live version every time.

• lunarrooftop October 31, 2026

  LMAO exactly 😭 Blinding Lights is undeniable but it’s been doing laps around the planet for years. Starboy gets the pick every time.

• orbitdemo99 October 31, 2026

  Starboy every single time 😮‍💨

• falsetto October 31, 2026

  That synth build is unreal, tbh.

• arcade_tape October 31, 2026

  Starboy, no hesitation.

• RetroTapes November 1, 2026

  Starboy. Blinding Lights is basically legally required to be played near a neon sign at this point; Starboy still has teeth.

• moonfox November 1, 2026

  Starboy. Blinding Lights is undeniable, but Starboy has that icy swagger I never get tired of 😮‍💨

• cosmic_head03 November 1, 2026

  Blinding Lights is the cleaner pop song, but I’m choosing Starboy for the attitude alone. 🖤

• ravenghost70 November 1, 2026

  Still picking Blinding Lights.

• rustycrowd11 November 4, 2026

  exactly, Starboy still hits

• coastallover November 4, 2026

  Starboy has more personality.

• HollowStatic November 4, 2026

  Blinding Lights, idc 😭 Starboy has the attitude, but that synth rush is still undefeated to me.